Haggard's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Messy robot Repair]

Good

Overall the song is pretty nice. There are loops and synths everywhere, but the "final product" turns out to be quite good.

The intro is a bit slow, and especially the part at 0:56 doesn't sound that good. The drums sound much too weak here, so you should try to get a more bassy sound for them.

But later, at around 1:37 the song gets really good. Here everything fits together quite well. Too bad the song ends so quickly after that. ^^

{ Review Request Club }

Sawdust responds:

Thanks, well appreciated.

[Lost Entity (Dance Remix)]

Good

A good song. It starts off slow in the intro but quickly builds up to a good dance song. I like the melodies you used here, they are simple but very catchy.

Also, the beat is good as well. Very driving, but not too "hard" either, so that people can just enjoy the song on the dancefloor without having to exhaust themselves too much. ^^

I like how you did the outro. It loops very good with the intro so that it's hardly noticable where the song ends and where it starts over.

Too bad it's so short, though. A few more parts sure would have been nice. It would make the song longer and less repetitive (because it gets repetitive after the 4th or 5th playthrough. ^^)

{ Review Request Club }

DJ-Chilvan responds:

Thnx! Ya, I was kinda disappointed it was a little short too. I am really considering an extended version, and it's like i will now make one due to the fact that I now have the full versions of the VSTs. I will make it not much longer, to avoid repetitiveness. I might add a couple more verses of different melodies.

Thnx again!

[[DX] Haunted Hip-Hop]

Interesting concept

Never really heard songs like this before. Well, there's the Insane Clown Posse with a few "scary songs", but they all sound different from this.

I like the main melody and the instrument you used for it. It sounds creepy and is very powerful. However, the song lacks some variation (as some of the reviewers already said before me). Even though the song is only 1:31 long we can hear the same elements being repeated quite often.

Some more melodies or drum beats would certainly help to make the song less repititve and it would also break up the song structure a bit, which would also be a nice thing. Because right now the song structure is too plain for my liking.

So, the basics for a good song are there. You have an interesting concept and a nice and powerful main melody. Now you just have to work on the rest. Though this "rest" can turn out to be the hardest work of the whole song. ^^

{ Review Request Club }

dx5231 responds:

my songs sound kinda repetitive, I guess I should start practicing.
Thanks for the review.

[LB - Your Beauty Defined]

Very nice

I like this song, it's very nice and has a good atmosphere. Also I think the intro is good as it is now. I like the slow fade in of the piano. Then when it is fully faded in, some other instruments join the piano. As I've said, I like it and I don't think you should change it (sorry aliaspharow, but I have to disagree with you here :P ).

Anyway, I think the song's strongess is that it is quite slow. You give the song time to develop, the melodies have a much better impact on the listener that way, imo. If you speed this up chances are that it all may sound too hectic and thus you would ruin the song.

However, there are sometimes a few background sounds that don't fit too good into the song, for example at 2:26. It just sounds a bit off to me.

{ Review Request Club }

Lublub194 responds:

2:26 you say? I don't hear anything off here? Maybe I'm missing something?

I'm very glad you enjoyed this! That makes me quite happy when others enjoy it too :)

I don't think I'll change the tempo at all, and if I do, It maybe a lil bit slower...

Thanks for the review :D

[Sg720 - Tonight]

Spacey

This song has a great and spacey atmosphere. It almost feels as if I'm sitting in some kind of spaceship flying through space. And sometimes the atmosphere is more like I'm sitting on the earth, watching the stars and wishing I would sit in a spaceship flying through space. XD

Anyway, I like the melodies in this song pretty much. They are catchy and even after listening to the song three times they still sound unique and fresh.
Also, the transitions between the slower and the faster parts is done pretty good. Those changes in speed also prevent the song from getting too repititve.

Only the outro isn't done that nicely. The song pretty much just ends there. I think a fade out while the main melody is playing would sound better. But on the other hand, fade outs are overdone, so it might be better to just leave the outro as it is now. ^^

{ Review Request Club }

sumguy720 responds:

Yeah, I am XOnstantly tipping between doing fade outs averagely and doing abrupt endings poorly.
Someday I'll get better at one or the other, and when I do I'll start concluding my songs with the utmost skill! Until then, I appreciate the feedback, I'll practice that from now on.

[Alien Relations - BK]

Good

I like the vocal samples you used throughout the song. They are a very nice addition and they fit pretty well into the song. Also otherwise the song might be a bit boring, as there seems to be nothing that stands out too much.

Don't get me wrong, I don't think this song is bad, it just seems to keep itself in the background a little bit too much for my liking.
Also one of the instruments you used sounds a bit strange (that one that starts at 0:29). To me it somehow sounds a bit "carribean" and it destroys a bit the nice extra terrestrian atmosphere you manage to create with the other sounds.

{ Review Request Club }

Bracksta responds:

i am workin on a remix of this song and hope to please :D. thanks for the tips and your opinion, it will help me shape the remix :). thanks for your time haggard :)

[[Dr.S] Keep On Movin']

Very nice

While listening to this I thought I was listening to some Deep Purple or Led Zepplin stuff, because the quality and the song is so awsome. This has to be among the top tracks for quality, it's just amazing.

Anyway, the song itself is amazing as well. Even though it's over 5 minutes long and it doesn't contain any vocals it never gets boring listening to it.
The build up may be a bit slow, though. The volume is turned down all the way and only rises very slowly. It takes over a minute before the song "really" starts (ie we can hear the music at full volume).
But we get a very nice reward for the long wait. The song that follows is just great. The solo guitar plays some very nice stuff here.

However, the drums could be worked out a bit better. The drums play only one riff during the beginning, a faster riff in the middle part and a mid tempo riff during the end part which sounds similar to the first riff. This can get repititve towards the end.

In my opinion it sounds better if every instrument gets a little "solo part" as this takes away from the repititveness of a single instruments.

{ Review Request Club }

Dr-Slump responds:

Thanks Haggard! Yeah, thinking critically about my song, I think I have the same opinion as you do. About the solo for each instrument... yeah, that's an interesting idea for a new song. Challenging, surely. I'm going to wait for christmas or something for a new pc. This one is almost 5 years old. 512 ram... it's hard to work with that, i can tell you that.

You guys at the review request club are really doing a great job! Keep up the good work. You guys make NG a happier place.

[Demon Voices]

Good

Isn't the band just called "Sunn O)))"? ;)

Anyway, this creates a really creepy atmosphere and the guitar in the background builds a very nice contrast to this with the calm (yet somehow creepy) melody it plays.

I also like how you slowly transit from the demonish intro to a pretty calm and hopefull ambiente, where we can only hear the guitar and some strings in the background.

The transition back to the demoic atmosphere isn't done so good, in my opinion, it happens too quickly. But on the other hand the song may have been too dragged out if you did this as slow and subtle as you did with the transition from "demonic" to "almost happy".

Also, in the beginning there are some statics noticable. I guess that's because some of the effects are too deep and bassy.

{ Review Request Club }

Monkeydelic responds:

You are 100% correct, it's Sunn O))) :P

I can work some more on the transition at the end when i re-record this song, maybe make it fade in together with the guitar.

Sadly, the static is impossible to avoid, i can limit it, but not get rid of it all together.

Thanks for the review :)

Namaste.

[The Ancient Ones]

Calm

Yeah, the title says it all. XD

This is indeed a very calm submission, but I like it. Sometimes you just need someting to calm down and this song certainly helps.

I like that you put so many different things in the background. I nearly missed half of those because I was busy doing other things. But then I read your comments and listened to the song again, and boy, those background noises make the song even more interesting.

However, that effect you use at around 6:57 doesn't really fit there in my opinion. It kind of disturbs the relaxing atmosphere, almost turning it into some kind of "David Lynch"-like movie score.

Also it's too bad the sound quality is a bit low. It all sounds kind of muffled, but I guess that's because your ways of recording the music are kind of kimited.

{ Review Request Club }

Monkeydelic responds:

Thanks :)

That's part of the challenge of making ambinet/mood spesific music, if you're not in the mood to be calm, you're just not gonna pay attention to the music, and I really appreciate you taking the time to really listen to my music :)

I must agree with you on the 6:57 sound affect, it was a random loop i found on the internet a long long time ago, back in those days I was annoyed by the restraints i had, so i always tried to find other elements to put in my music, and without thinking to much about how it would fit the rest of the song, i just slapped in on there.

Thanks for review :)

Namaste.

[Aleos (Take2)]

Sounds different than the first version...

Of course, the melodies are the same, the bell at the intro... but with the added stuff the atmosphere is quite different.

It's not bad, but I find it hard to compare it to the previous version now. This second take still creates a dark and creepy atmosphere, but now it doesn't sound so... hopeless anymore. It sounds more "encouragin" now. As if the music wasn't there to creep out the player but to help him not to give up.

So, I can't say if this version sounds better than the old one. But it is without doubt different. :)

{ Review Request Club }

Kirbyfemur responds:

Haha, thanks. At this point I'm just trying some new things with it. Most likely I'll e leaving it alone for a while. But We'll see what happens in the future. Thanks for the review=3