Haggard's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Stargenx - PsyRockin]

Good

I think the sound of the guitars is actually quite good. Sure, they sound artificial, but it sounds better than most artificial guitars I have heard so far.
Also, learning to play the guitar isn't that hard. If I can do it, everybody can. :P

Anyway, I like this song. The intro is very good, I like the riff here.
The little soli in the song sound nice as well, though some more riffs would sound good here as well. They would break the song up a bit and make it longer. Right now the song goes like this: Intro riff, solo, short break, solo 2, end.
I think if you would add another riff part after the break it would sound a bit better.

Anyway, overall the song sounds good, but there's still some room for improvement.

{ Review Request Club }

Stargenx responds:

Thanks for the review!
I kept this one simple. I know it's not my best but I like it. I didn't want to stray off the pattern too much and screw it up.

["Frozen Clockwork" -GST Mix-]

Fast

Wow, this is indeed a very fast song. The intro is really amazing with that fast paced beat. I also like the build up of the song, it's very nice how we can at first only hear the beat and then slowly other elements set in.

However, the first half of the song gets a bit repetitive, maybe you could try to bring some more variation in there by breaking the beat up a bit or something.

The second half is much better in my opinion as you added a lot more varity into the song in that half.

{ Review Request Club }

Dj-GST responds:

Thanks for the awesome review man!

I'm glad you like the intro, I worked pretty hard in getting that exactly the way I wanted.

I know the drums are a bit repetitive, I'll work on varying them a bit more.

Thanks, I was trying for a more "epic" feel to the second half, I'm glad you liked it.

Thanks for the review man, I appreciate it :)

[Dragon Flight - BK]

Very good

It's really hard to review this song. Not because it's bad (that would be easy to review ^^) but because it's so complex.

It took me quite a while to get into the song, as if found this song very unusual, especially the main beat.
But also the melodies do a lot of almost crazy stuff in this song.

But it is also great that I have to spent time to get into this song. I had fun experiencing new things every time when I listened to this again.

Too bad there's some buzz on the piano, it prevents me from giving you the 10 points this song deserves. But the buzzing is too annoying at times. :(

{ Review Request Club }

Bracksta responds:

thanks for the great review :). I completely agree about the buzz on the piano, if you read the commentary you will see why it is that way :(. Glad i could make you ponder and jam out a lil :). till next time haggard, peace :)

[BOUNC3 BirfdaySong!]

Good song

The tempo of the song is very nice, I like the upbeat drums in the background. The melodies are good as well, they create a great clublike atmosphere.

I also like the diversity of the melodies. There's always something new that's happening which makes the song really interesting. Too bad the background beat seems to stay more or less the same all the time. You should try to change that around a bit as well.

{ Review Request Club }

Box-Killa responds:

Note taken, change background beat sometime...

[Capital katlean (remix)]

Good song

A very good song. I really like the rhythm here. Especially in the first part of the song. It reminds me of "Übers Jahr" by Wolfsheim (I doubt you ever heard it, but the way the piano plays sounds similar).

Anyway, the melodies that set in later also sound very good. They fit nicely to the rhythm, even though both elements create different atmospheres. The rhythm sounds "heavy" and creates a quite darkish atmosphere. The melody on the other hand sounds very "light" and creates a brighter atmosphere.

The second part of the song reminds me of France, heh. The accordion reminds me of some french street cafés for some reason. ^^

{ Review Request Club }

Calamaistr responds:

Sorry for taking a bit to respond, been very busy with the album im working on heh. (i wont post them anywhere for reviews untill the whole thing is done though, because its a total picture really)

So about your review here.

I dont know ubers jahr to be honest no, ill look it up sometime.
hmm, i like folk-instruments wich is why i picked the accordion.. i also like the characteristics of the instrument, ill be making music with it more often i think.. its very similar to certain synths i used to frequent back on the console.

I never really listened to the rythm myself to be honest.. funnily.. i just liked the drag and the melody kind of made itself as i was in 'the zone' of making it. :)

And again, thanks for the review. :)

[Kaleidoscope Eye]

Strange

A very strange song. The vocals in the beginning sound very funny, but I couldn't make out what they where saying (or if they are supposed to say anything meaningful at all).

The song doesn't seem to go anywhere, though. I think a few more instruments would sound good here, as they would give us something more to listen to.

Also the outro doesn't really fit to the song, in my opinion you should change it.

{ Review Request Club \

TheSongSalad responds:

Thanks for the review man.

[Stargenx - Magical Pipe]

Great song

This song reminds me of some of the music that is played in some documentaries, heh. It just has the same "mystical yet relaxing" atmosphere to it.

I like the drums here a lot. They are very set back and yet they are audible enough to give this song a nice structure.
I really like how you made the pipe the main instrument in this song, you don't hear songs like this very often in the audio portal.

Good work!

{ Review Request Club }

Stargenx responds:

Thanks! I often make some of my best songs late at night. This was one of them. That late period at night when your mind is so lucid and clear....

I love it. Thanks again for the good review!

[In My Dreams - Jxl180]

Good song

This is a very nice song. The melodies and the beat sound pretty good and I love the deep bass you used.

The vocals are a very nice addition, they fit good into the song, even though they are a bit too quiet when they first set in. They are nearly drowned out by the other instruments, so you may want to have a look at that again.

{ Review Request Club }

jxl180 responds:

OK, thank you for the review. I'll check it out.

[power of Drum&Bass.V2]

Nice song but still room for improvement

The voices are really cool and they fit pretty good to the song. However, I think you also should add some voices during the middle parts of the song, this would make it even better.

The melodies are pretty loud, they nearly drown out the background beat from time to time, so I think you should turn down the volume on the melodies a tad bit.

Also the song gets a bit repetitive towards the end and a bit overloaded. I'm not too happy with that instrument that sets in at 2:29. It sounds good at first because it adds something new to the song and breaks up the repetitiveness a bit, but it plays for too long in my opinion. Especially when the melodies play at full power again it all becomes a bit too much.

Overall the song is nice, but it needs a bit more work here and there.

{ Review Request Club }

jpgregorio responds:

thanks, that instrument was put in there to break the repetitiveness. i'll just keep making improvements, bye.

[p4c-Maleficence [Short Mix] HQ]

Good mix of genres

The mixing of genres is pretty nice in this song. It's a bit weird at first how fast it changes sometimes, but it really grew on me while I listened to this song.

The clapping sound is a bit annoying, though. It doesn't really fit in the song (maybe you should try and use a snare drum) and it's overused anyway.

My favorite part is when we can hear that piano playing a melody and then the awesome deep bass sets in right after that (at around 0:50 for example).

{ Review Request Club }

p4c responds:

yeah i wasnt feelin the clapping during the harpsichord sections and i wasnt sure what sound id use to replace it with, though perhaps eliminating the clap for the whole song might work out? ill try it. and as for changing pretty often, each section was cut down pretty short for the purposes of making teh song short, so that probably contributed to the hectic feel of the song. regardless, im glad you liked it and ill probably be expanding this into a full length track to pitch out to the records ;) thanks for enjoyin the song!